When your home purchase doesn't make it to closing, understanding what happens to your earnest money can mean the difference between getting your deposit back and losing thousands of dollars. The rules around earnest money aren't as straightforward as many buyers assume, and knowing how these situations typically unfold in Franklin can help you protect your interests from the start.
Your earnest money deposit shows the seller you're serious about purchasing their home. In Franklin's current market, these deposits typically range from $1,000 to $5,000 for homes under $500,000, and often represent 1-2% of the purchase price for higher-value properties. This money gets held in an escrow account, usually by the listing agent's brokerage or a title company, until closing.
The key point many buyers miss is that earnest money isn't automatically refundable just because the deal falls apart. Your purchase contract spells out exactly when you can walk away and keep your deposit, and when the seller has a claim to those funds.
Your purchase contract includes specific contingencies that allow you to cancel the agreement and recover your earnest money. In Franklin, the most common contingencies are:
Inspection contingency: If significant issues surface during your home inspection, you typically have a set number of days to request repairs or cancel the contract. The seller can choose not to make repairs, at which point you can walk away with your earnest money intact.
Financing contingency: When you can't secure a mortgage despite making good faith efforts, this contingency protects your deposit. Your contract will specify exactly how long you have to get loan approval and what documentation you need to provide if financing falls through.
Appraisal contingency: If the home appraises for less than your offer price and the seller won't negotiate, you can typically cancel and keep your earnest money.
Sale of existing home contingency: Less common in Franklin's competitive market, but if your contract includes this provision, you're protected if your current home doesn't sell within the specified timeframe.
Every contingency in your contract has specific deadlines, and missing these dates can cost you your earnest money even if you have legitimate concerns about the property. For example, if your inspection contingency gives you seven days to respond after receiving the inspection report, submitting your repair requests on day eight could void your protection.
Many buyers assume they have until their contingency period ends to make a decision, but the contract language often requires you to take action within a certain number of days after receiving specific information. Reading these timelines carefully—and putting key dates on your calendar—protects your deposit.
Sometimes both buyer and seller believe they have a rightful claim to the earnest money. This typically happens when the buyer wants to cancel for reasons not clearly covered by contract contingencies, or when there's disagreement about whether contingency deadlines were properly met.
In Tennessee, the escrow holder (usually a real estate brokerage or title company) cannot release disputed earnest money without written agreement from both parties or a court order. This means your money could sit in limbo for months while the dispute gets resolved.
Common scenarios that lead to disputes include buyers who want to cancel due to job loss or family emergencies not covered by contract contingencies, situations where repair negotiations break down but neither party clearly rejected the other's proposals in writing, or cases where buyers miss contingency deadlines but argue they weren't properly notified.
The best protection starts when you write your offer. Understanding each contingency and its timeline gives you clear exit strategies if problems arise. Work with your agent to build realistic deadlines that give you adequate time for inspections, loan processing, and decision-making without unnecessarily extending the contingency periods.
Keep detailed records of all communication with your lender, inspector, and agent. If you need to cancel based on a contingency, having documentation that shows you met all requirements and deadlines strengthens your position.
When repair negotiations stall, communicate your decisions in writing within your contract deadlines. Even if conversations are ongoing, formally exercising your right to cancel within the contingency period protects your earnest money while you continue discussions.
While sellers can theoretically pursue buyers for earnest money through the courts, the practical reality in Franklin is that most disputes get resolved through negotiation. The cost and time involved in legal action often outweigh the earnest money amount, especially for deposits under $5,000.
However, this doesn't mean you should ignore contract terms or assume you can walk away without consequences. Sellers who believe a buyer cancelled in bad faith may be more willing to pursue the matter, particularly in cases involving larger deposits or when they've incurred significant costs due to the cancelled sale.
Understanding your contract's earnest money provisions before you sign, tracking all deadlines carefully, and communicating decisions promptly gives you the best chance of protecting your deposit if your home purchase doesn't work out as planned. When problems arise, working through the proper contract procedures rather than simply walking away keeps you on solid ground regardless of what happens next.
Excellence, Without Exception.™
At Redbird Real Estate, we specialize in residential sales, property management, and commercial real estate services in and around Franklin,...
Franklin, Tennessee
View full profile